The First Hour Following Birth - Perspectives
Perspectives
by Michel Odent, September 2002
The hour following birth is undoubtedly one of the most critical phases in the life of human beings. It is not by chance that all human groups have routinely disturbed the physiological processes in this short period of time, via beliefs and rituals. Our cultural milieus are to a great extent shaped at the very beginning of the mother-newborn interaction.
The first hour following birth may be looked at from a multitude of complementary perspectives. My objective is to catalogue 12 such perspectives to demonstrate the real dimension of this enormous subject.
Perspective 1 - The sudden need to breathe
We do not need to develop this widely documented perspective. It is well understood that during the first hour following birth the baby must suddenly use its lungs. This implies, in particular, that the heart must urgently pump blood to the pulmonary circulation. The prerequisite is that the pulmonary and systemic circulations separate by closure of the connections between them (ductus arteriosus and foramen ovale).
Perspective 2 - The behavioral effects of hormones
This perspective needs to be developed, so recent are the available data.
Today we are in a position to explain that all the different hormones released by mother and fetus during the first and second stages of labor are not yet eliminated during the hour following birth. All of them have a specific role to play in the mother-newborn interaction. Until recently the behavioral effects of these hormones had not even been suspected.
The key hormone involved in birth physiology is undoubtedly oxytocin. Its mechanical effects have been well known for a long time (effects on uterine contractions for the birth of the baby and the delivery of the placenta; effects on the contractions of the myo-epithelial cells of the breast for the milk ejection reflex). Prange and Pedersen demonstrated the behavioral effects of oxytocin for the first time in 1979 via experimentation with rats: An injection of oxytocin directly into the brain of virgin rats induced a maternal behavior. This experiment laid the foundation for a new generation of studies. The results of hundreds of such studies can be summarized in one or two sentences: Oxytocin is the typical altruistic hormone; it is involved whatever the facet of love one considers.
These data appear important when one knows that, according to Swedish studies, it is after the birth of the baby and before the delivery of the placenta that women have the capacity to reach the highest possible peak of oxytocin. As in any other circumstances (for example sexual intercourse or lactation) the release of oxytocin is highly dependent on environmental factors. It is easier if the place is very warm (so that the level of hormones of the adrenaline family is as low as possible). It is also easier if the mother has nothing else to do but look at the baby's eyes and feel contact with the baby's skin, without any distraction. The way oxytocin is released is a new avenue for research. To be effective, this release must be pulsatile: The higher the frequency of pulses, the more effective this hormone is.
Oxytocin is never released in isolation. It is always part of a complex hormonal balance. That is why love has so many facets. In the particular case of the hour following birth, in physiological conditions, the high peak of oxytocin is associated with a high level of prolactin, which is also known as the "motherhood hormone." This is the most typical situation for inducing love of babies. Oxytocin and prolactin complement each other. Furthermore, estrogens activate the oxytocin and prolactin receptors. We must always think in terms of hormonal balance.
It was also in 1979 that the maternal release of morphine-like hormones during labor and delivery was demonstrated. The release of these endorphins is now well documented. In the early 1980s we learned that the baby also releases its own endorphins in the birth process, and today there is no doubt that, for a certain time following birth, both mother and baby are impregnated with opiates. The property of opiates to induce states of dependency is well known, so it is easy to anticipate how the beginning of a "dependency"-or attachment-will likely develop.
Even hormones of the adrenaline family (often seen as hormones of aggression) have an obvious role to play in the interaction between mother and baby immediately after birth. During the very last contractions before birth the level of these hormones in the mother peaks. That is why, in physiological conditions, as soon as the "fetus ejection reflex" starts, women tend to be upright, full of energy, with a sudden need to grasp something or someone. They often need to drink a glass of water, just as a speaker may do in front of a large audience. One of the effects of such adrenaline release is that the mother is alert when the baby is born. Think of mammals in the wild, and we can more clearly understand how advantageous it is for the mother to have enough energy-and aggressiveness-to protect her newborn baby if need be. Aggressiveness is an aspect of maternal love. It is also well known that the baby has its own survival mechanisms during the last strong expulsive contractions and releases its own hormones of the adrenaline family. A rush of noradrenaline enables the fetus to adapt to the physiological oxygen deprivation specific to this stage of delivery. The visible effect of this hormonal release is that the baby is alert at birth, with eyes wide open and dilated pupils. Human mothers are fascinated and delighted by the gaze of their newborn babies. It is as if the baby was giving a signal, and it certainly seems that this human eye-to-eye contact is an important feature of the beginning of the mother and baby relationship among humans.
The highly complex role of hormones of the adrenaline-noradrenaline family in the interaction between mother and baby has not been studied for a long time. A small number of animal experiments open the way to further research. Mice that lack a gene responsible for the production of noradrenaline leave their pups scattered, unclean and unfed, unless they are injected with a noradrenaline-producing drug when giving birth.
From the hormonal perspective it appears clearly that sexuality comes full circle. In all the different episodes of our sexual life the same hormones are released and similar scenarios are reproduced. For example, during sexual intercourse, both partners-male and female-release oxytocin and endorphins. It is the beginning of an attachment that is following the same model as the mother-baby attachment during the hour following birth.
Our current knowledge of the behavioral effects of different hormones involved in the birth process helps us to interpret the concept of a sensitive period introduced by ethologists. It is clear that all the different hormones released by the mother and by the baby during labor and delivery are not eliminated immediately. It is also clear that all of them have a specific role to play in the later interactions between mother and baby.
Perspective 3 - The perspective of ethologists
Ethologists observe the behaviors of animals and human beings. They often study one particular behavior in a number of unrelated species. They were the first scientists who claimed that, in terms of mother-newborn attachment among birds and mammals, there is a short yet crucial period immediately after birth that will never be repeated. Harlow studied in particular the process of attachment among primates.
The importance of the ethological approach is gradually emerging after the recent discovery of the behavioral effects of hormones involved in the birth process.
An ethological study of the first hour following birth among humans is difficult because the physiological processes are routinely disturbed. However, it is possible in unusual circumstances. Imagine a woman who gave birth in her own bathroom while her husband was shopping. She is in a very warm and quite dark place. She does not feel observed at all. However, from the crack of the door you can catch a glimpse of the scene now and then. By combining what you learned from different stories like that, you'll be in a position to describe a stereotyped behavior. First, the mother looks at her newborn baby between her legs. After a while she dares to touch her with her fingertips. Then she becomes more and more audacious and wants to hold her baby in her arms. At that time most women are as if fascinated by the baby's eyes.
Perspective 4 - The first hour as the beginning of lactation
There was a time, not so long ago, when we wouldn't have considered the first hour following birth as the time when lactation is supposed to start. Imagine a baby born at home a century ago. The cord was cut right away. Then the baby was washed, dressed and shown to the mother before being put in a crib. An anecdote can help us realize how recent this perspective is. In 1977, in Rome, at the Congress of Psychosomatic, Gynaecology and Obstetrics, I presented a paper about the early expression of the rooting reflex. I was simply describing the ideal conditions that allow the baby to find the breast during the first hour following birth. None of the obstetricians and pediatricians present at that session could believe that a human baby would be able to find the breast during the hour following birth.
Today most midwives know that the human baby is naturally programmed to find the breast during the hour following birth. Moreover, one can understand that, in physiological conditions, when the newborn baby is ready to find the breast, the mother is still in a particular hormonal balance. She is still "on another planet." She is still very instinctive. She knows how to hold her baby. Among humans, breastfeeding is potentially instinctive-during the hour following birth. After that there is room for education, imitation and even technique.
Perspective 5 - First hour and metabolic adaptation
As long as the baby is in the womb the nutrients, particularly the vital fuel glucose, are provided in a continuous mode via the cord. Immediately after birth the baby must adapt to a discontinuous supply. The remarkable ability of the neonate to respond to significantly low glucose value has been studied in depth by M. Cornblath in the United States, and by Jane Hawdon, Laura Derooy and Suzanne Colson (see "Womb to World," Midwifery Today Issue 61, page 12) in the United Kingdom.
Perspective 6 - The bacteriological point of view
At birth, a baby is germ-free. An hour later there are millions of germs covering her mucous membranes. To be born is to enter the world of microbes. The question is, which germs will be the first to colonize the baby's body? Bacteriologists know that the winners of the race will be the rulers of the territory. The germ environment of the mother is already familiar and friendly from the perspective of the newborn because mother and baby share the same antibodies (IgG). In other words, from a bacteriological point of view, the newborn human baby urgently needs to be in contact with only one person-her mother. If we add that early consumption of colostrum will help establish an ideal gut flora, there is no doubt that, from a bacteriological point of view, the hour following birth is a critical period with lifelong consequences. Our gut flora can be presented as an aspect of our personality that cannot be easily modified later on in life.
Perspective 7 - Starting up the process of thermoregulation
While in the womb the baby never had any opportunity to experience differences in temperature (apart from possible episodes of maternal fever). Once more, the first minutes following birth appear as an interruption of continuity. As the mechanisms of thermoregulation are not yet mature at birth there are theoretical reasons to be worried about the cases of maternal hyperthermia during labor that are induced by an epidural anesthesia or a too hot bath. Such situations might challenge in a dangerous way the thermoregulation of the baby by exaggerating the differences of temperature between the intra- and the extra-uterine environments.
Perspective 8 - Adaptation to gravity
During the first hour a new relationship to gravity is established. Suddenly the vestibular nerve, which serves equilibrium, is carrying to the brain an unprecedented flood of impulses from the semicircular canals, utricles and saccules.
Perspective 9 - The ethnological approach
Ethnology has established itself as a science by publishing databases. Today its material on pregnancy, childbirth and the first days following birth is easily accessed.
Most cultures disturb the first contact between mother and baby during the hour following birth. The most universal and intriguing way is simply to promote a belief, such as the belief that colostrum is tainted or harmful to the baby, even a substance to be expressed and discarded. Such a belief necessitates that, immediately after birth, the baby must not be in her mother's arms. This implies rituals such as the ritual of cutting the cord immediately. The first contact between mother and baby can be disturbed through many other rituals: bathing, rubbing, tight swaddling, foot binding, "smoking" the baby, piercing the ears of the little girls, opening the doors in cold countries, etc.
It would take volumes to present a comprehensive study of the characteristics of a great number of cultures in relation to how they challenge the maternal protective instinct during the sensitive period following birth. However a simple conclusion can be drawn from a rapid overview of the data we have at our disposal: The greater the social need for aggression and an ability to destroy life, the more intrusive the rituals and beliefs are in the period surrounding birth.
If disturbing the first contact between mother and baby and promulgating such excuses as the belief that colostrum is bad are so universal, it means that these behaviors have carried evolutionary advantages.
After taking into account and combining all the perspectives that indicate the importance of the hour following birth, and after referring to perinatal rituals and beliefs, we are in a position to claim that the cultural milieus are to a great extent shaped during the hour following birth. Now we can consider the hour following birth in the context of our modern societies.
Perspective 10 - The obstetrical approach
All these considerations were necessary before looking at the hour following birth in the context of our modern societies. In our societies the cultural control of childbirth is mostly a medical control.
From medical literature and textbooks it appears that, in obstetrical circles, the question is: "How do you manage the so-called third stage?" Medical journals periodically publish prospective randomized, controlled studies comparing different ways to "manage" the third stage. The only objective is to evaluate the risks of postpartum hemorrhage. These studies are conducted in the context of large obstetrical units. All research protocols use a negative definition of "expectant management" (e.g., no use of uterotonic drugs and no clamping of the cord). The factors that can positively facilitate the release of oxytocin are not included in the protocols. The results of such trials have led to the practice of routinely injecting oxytocic substances into all mothers at the very time of the birth of the baby. Such substances block the release of the natural hormone; furthermore they have no behavioral effects. The effects of these obstetrical routines must be considered in terms of civilization.
Perspective 11 - The midwifery approach
Certain midwives can still practice authentic midwifery. This means they are not prisoners of strict guidelines and protocols. They can play their role of protectors of the physiological processes. Immediately after the birth of the baby the main preoccupation of such midwives is the release by the mother of a high peak of oxytocin because it is necessary for safe delivery of the placenta and is the hormone of love.
They first make sure the room is warm enough. During the third stage women never complain that it is too hot. If they are shivering, it means the place is not warm enough. In the case of a homebirth, the only important tool to prepare is a transportable heater that can be plugged in any place and at any time and can be used to warm blankets or towels. Their other goal is to make sure the mother is not distracted at all while looking at the baby's eyes and feeling contact with the baby's skin. There are countless avoidable ways of distracting mother and baby at that stage. The mother can be distracted because she feels observed or guided, because somebody is talking, because the birth attendant wants to cut the cord before the delivery of the placenta, because the telephone rings, or because a light is suddenly switched on, etc. At that stage, after a birth in physiological conditions, the mother is still in a particular state of consciousness, as if "on another planet." Her neocortex is still more or less at rest. The watchword should be, "Don't wake up the mother!"
Perspective 12 - A political note
It makes sense that studying the third stage of labor from non medical perspectives makes many people - particularly doctors - feel uncomfortable. Any approach that might lead us to reconsider our attitudes during this short period of time is shaking the very foundations of our cultures. Research can be politically incorrect. Politically incorrect research includes certain aspects of 'Primal Health research', particularly studies exploring the long term consequences of how we are born. The findings of important such studies about topical issues (e.g. juvenile criminality, teenager suicide, drug addiction, anorexia nervosa, autism, etc.) are shunned by the medical community and the media, despite their publication in authoritative medical or scientific journals. Politically incorrect research leads to 'cul-de-sac epidemiology'.
Further reading
Odent M. The Scientification of Love. Free association books. London 1999
Oxytocin in maternal, sexual and social behaviors. Perdersen CA, et al. edit. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. 1992; vol.652
Pedersen CS, Prange J.R. Induction of maternal behavior in virgin rats after intracerebroventricular administration of oxytocin. Pro. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1979; 76: 6661-65
Verbalis J.G., McCann M, McHale CM, Stricker EM. Oxytocin secretion in response to cholecystokinin and food: differentiation of nausea from satiety Science 1986; 232: 1417-19
Nissen E, Lilja G, Widstrom AM, Uvnas-Moberg K. Elevation of oxytocin levels early post partum in women. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 1995 ; 74 : 530-3
Zarrow MX, Gandelman R, Renenberg V. Prolactin: is it an essential hormone for maternal behavior in the mammal? Horm. Behav. 1971; 2: 343-54
Csontos K, Rust M, et al. Elevated plasma beta endorphin levels in pregnant women and their neonates. Life Sci. 1979; 25: 835-44
Akil H, Watson S.J. et al. Beta endorphin immunoreactivity in rat and human blood: Radio-immunoassay, comparative levels and physiological alternatives. Life Sci. 1979; 24: 1659-66
Moss IR, Conner H, et al. Human beta endorphin-like immunoreactivity in the perinatal/neonatal period, J. of Ped. 1982; 101; 3: 443-46
Kimball CD, Chang CM, et al. Immunoreactive endorphin peptides and prolactin in umbilical vein and maternal blood. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 1987; 14: 104-105
Odent M. The early expression of the rooting reflex. Proceedings of the 5th International Congress of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Rome 1977. London: Academic Press, 1977: 1117-19.
Odent M. Colostrum and civilization. In: The Nature of birth and breastfeeding. Bergin and Garvey. Westport, CT. 1992
Prendeville W, Harding J, Elbourne D, Stirrat G. The Bristol third stage trial: active versus physiological management of the third stage of labour. BMJ 1988; 297: 1295-300
Rogers J, Wood J, McCandish R, et al. Active versus expectant management of third stage of labour: the Hinchingbrooke randomized controlled trial. Lancet 1998; 351: 693-99.
Odent M. Don't manage the third stage of labour! The Practising midwife 1998; 1 (9): 31-33.
Odent M. Active versus expectant management of third stage of labour. Lancet 1998; 351: 1659.
Odent M. Between circular and cul-de-sac epidemiology. Lancet 2000; 355: 1371.
Dr. med. Michel Odent, geboren 1930, studierte Medizin in Paris und leitete mehr als 20 Jahre die geburtshilfliche Abteilung eines Krankenhauses. Seine Ansichten des psychologischen Verständnisses um die Geburt führten zu einer innovativen Geburtshilfe: gebärenden Frauen ermöglichte er bereits in den 70er Jahren völlige Privatsphäre und freie Entscheidungen unter der Geburt und eine respektvolle Geburtsbegleitung von Frau zu Frau. Erstmals im europäischen Raum schuf er die Möglichkeit der Geburt im Wasser. Im Krankenhaus von Pithivièrs richtete er Geburtszimmer ein, dort gab es auch die ersten "Gebärwannen". Seine Studien und Forschungsergebnisse zu Wassergeburten sind bis heute richtungsweisend.
Der Zustrom von Frauen und die Verbreitung seiner humanen Ideen innerhalb kurzer Zeit gaben ihm Recht, es setzte bei vielen Menschen ein völlig neues Bewusstsein im Hinblick auf selbstbestimmte Geburt ein, das richtungsweisend für viele GeburtshelferInnen und Gebärkliniken in Europa wurde. Odent hat deutlich gemacht, dass es wichtig ist, den gebärenden Frauen Entscheidungen rund um die Geburt selbst zu überlassen, ohne dass dies schädlich oder gefährlich ist - im Gegenteil: er hat bewiesen, dass diese humane Geburtshilfe nicht nur sicher ist, sondern auch dauerhaft positive Auswirkungen auf die seelische und körperliche Gesundheit von Mutter und Kind hat.
Bis heute hat Michel Odent sich stets vehement für die Würde der gebärenden Frauen und ihrer Kinder eingesetzt. Dies begründet die ihm weltweit entgegengebrachte Achtung und Anerkennung.
Michael Odent: Is the father's participation at birth dangerous?
ttp://www.michelodent.com/news.php?id=10
Biography Michel Odent
http://www.midwiferytoday.com/bio/odent.asp
Deutsche Bücher von Michel Odent:
Geburt und Stillen
Über die Natur elementarer Erfahrungen
C.H.Beck 2000; ISBN: 3406459838
Wir alle sind Kinder des Wassers
Kösel 1995; ISBN: 3466343313
Die Wurzeln der Liebe
Wie unsere wichtigsten Emotionen entstehen
Walter-Verlag 2001; ISBN: 353042157X
Die sanfte Geburt
Die Leboyer-Methode in der Praxis
Kösel; ISBN: 346634008X
Die Geburt des Menschen
Kösel; ISBN: 3466340365
Erfahrungen mit der sanften Geburt
Kösel; ISBN: 3466341523